Search Starr Island Cottage Rentals

"Great location for fishing and swimming. Lots of sun and shade. Great views from the property. Water was a great temp for swimming and cooling off. Roomy cottage with all amenities needed for an enjoyable stay."

"Nice location and great access to bala groceries and shops. Nice little beach. Nice kayaks, older paddle boat, and shallow water for little kids. Cottage is aging and kept up well. Pillows, linens, and beds are basic and adequate. Great air conditioning. Small washer and dryer was a must for two little kids. Host took a while to respond to messages and there were no checkout instructions, even after sending a message, other than depart by 1100 from the checkin message v"

"The location is good. Close to the beach and grocery store. The swim area access slippery and rocky so I recommend to bring water shoes. The lake is not too busy with motor boats so we were able to catch some fish. The hosts were nice and responsive. Overall nice stay."

"I was highly impressed with the cabin's exterior and interior. Plenty of surrounding forest. Plenty of muskoka villages and lakes nearby. Scenery aplenty.Also, lots of places to go hiking. Wonderful restaurants and cafes."

"Beautiful spot with incredible view. Just a few minor details overlooked. More cooking pots/pans would be handy, as well as additional tea, towels, washcloths, and dish cloths. A recommendation might be to cut back the trees in the entrance slightly as to allow for a safer exit onto busy roadway. Overall, Wonderful for a relaxing vacation. Paddle boards on site were certainly appreciated. "

"Zan was very helpful and the cottage was perfect for a couple. Will be back! "

"The cottage was perfect for our family reunion. Big enough for 11 adults and two children. The floor plan is spacious, so we never felt cramped. Some things in the house are a bit old, but still functional. We found the furnishings tasteful and harmonious. The kitchen equipment is sufficient even for a large group. There were also more than enough seating options. There are many watercrafts, both for children and adults. We had a great time, surrounded by nature. Communication with the owner was...

"The property is beautiful and access to the lake is perfect! "

"We stayed at the Stephen's cottage just recently. It's a nice place with everything you need for a relaxing stay for a few days. The cottage was clean and neatly prepared when we arrived, with all electronics working properly. Pictures match the reality accurately. Overall, a very pleasant experience. Just note that in winter there is not much to do in the area. "

"Cottage was great…shower upstairs not working & key was missing to treadmill but everything else was good. Henry is very responsive & replies to messages immediately "

"We really enjoyed our family getaway over the Labour Day. The cottage is cute and is a close drive to Bala. It would be have been preferable to be waterfront or have better lake access but the place was clean, the owners were nice and the area is still lovely. "

"It was absolutely a pleasure to stay at this cottage!!"