Sugarloaf Key Vacation Rentals

Plan, book, stay with confidence

Be picky

Search almost a million properties worldwide

Treat yourself

Change your mind

Book hotels with free cancellation

Check prices for these dates

Next weekend

In two weeks

In one month

In two months

Browse Select Sugarloaf Key Vacation Homes

"Perfect location, very cute clean place. Would definitely recommend and I will be back"

"Had a blast. Great location and accommodation "

"The place was cute; we had everything we needed and it was convenient to all the fun w/o being too close to all the noise and busyness of Duval St. Loved it!"

"This property is centrally located and we easily biked around to everything. There were restaurants and a gas station in walking distance. The surrounding neighborhood is quiet and neighbors were friendly and quiet. The bed was so comfortable, and the adjustable head of bed was so nice! I feel the price may have been on the high side due to Spring Break. I’d like to stay again and hope the price may be more reasonable in other times of the year.Overall, we loved the place and the location."

"We just needed a place for a couple of nights so that we could make the day trip to Dry Tortugas NP. This fit the bill! It wasn’t fancy but we felt safe and were easily able to fit our family of 5. But I wouldn’t have stayed for longer than 2 nights as we would’ve been cramped. We had everything we needed and all the necessary instructions ahead of time. And the view off of the back deck was pretty incredible! Also, if you don’t have a sound machine, be prepared for a rooster alarm clock!"

"Nice spacious property. Comfortable and clean. Plenty of space a great location if you prefer a little more quiet for evenings. Would definitely stay again."

"We loved staying at this house! Truly an oasis in Key West - privacy, pool and pool setting was awesome, easy to walk to everything Key West has to offer! Everything was clean, comfortable and equipped with everything we needed. Can't wait to go back!"

"Nothing but great things to say about the house, location and communications with property managers. And what's not to like about having 3 bathrooms, especially with a larger family like ours. Just walk in and start enjoying key west. It's half a block from Duval St. and about a 5 minute walk to Southern Most."

"Great place that provides easy access to Duval street, is clean with adequate amenities. The property is fully gated and feels very secure. The parking garage "

CA $1,198 total

includes taxes & fees

Apr 14 - Apr 15

"Wonderful property. Close to everything but also quiet. Had plenty of room for 2 adults and 3 grown children. Would highly recommend it. The heated pool was great! "

"Absolutely a gorgeous property and fantastic location. Key West is our favorite place to visit. This house, along with the property manager, made this year's visit the best yet! Thanks for a great birthday and we look forward to booking this property again next year"

"This house was perfect for our couples weekend! Two master king suits with their own private bathrooms. Location was excellent, we were in walking distance to Duval and the marinas. The rental company was great at letting us know about early check in and let us store our bags in their office when needed. There is a grocery store right across the street from the house. "

"After reading the other reviews I packed my air mattresses… didn’t need them the beds were fine. The patio rail is fixed based on a previous post. Only 1 working TV but not a big deal. 2 built in ovens but neither works, not ideal for larger family to use a small toaster oven. The place was clean and you can’t beat the location. "

CA $875 total

includes taxes & fees

Apr 25 - Apr 26

"This was the perfect place for our family to stay. It was very clean and great location. We will be back for sure!"

"This home is fully dialed in. Beautiful finishings, all the towels, sunscreen, and pool accessories you could ask for, and a perfect layout with gorgeous private pool and beautifully landscaped backyard space. Would definitely stay here again!"

CA $3,604 total

includes taxes & fees

Apr 13 - Apr 14

"Nice location. Comfortable place although the couch and living room chair were old and stained. "

CA $841 total

includes taxes & fees

Apr 20 - Apr 21

"Location. Location. Location. One block off Duval St and near everything. We rented a car but didn’t need it. Walked everywhere. "

"This property is amazingly situated and very well appointed. We have stayed here several times, and it does not disappoint in any respect. The convenience of location (and parking) is amazing and cannot be beat. It's enough off the main street to be comfortably quiet, but you can still enjoy the live music at a level which does not impede conversation while outside. Super clean with high end finishes. The private pool is mostly shaded, which is wonderfully refreshing after being out and about."

"Sam, Charlie and Vic were great"

"We stayed for four nights. They have ample beds, a nice tv, a large kitchen, and many parking spots. There are not many walkable beaches but there is a couple of good restaurants nearby. We had a great time, everything was nice, and everything was as listed. I would rent again. "

CA $1,081 total

includes taxes & fees

May 7 - May 8

Save an average of 15% on thousands of hotels when you're signed in

Other property types in Sugarloaf Key

2 Bedroom Aqua Lodge # 13 Barracuda | Living area

"Good experience, clean house and safe !"

CA $358 total

includes taxes & fees

Apr 13 - Apr 14

"Absolutely loved this property. Very affordable, cozy and good quality stays. Be ready for a little fish smell when walking outside! But I did not mind that. "

CA $416 total

includes taxes & fees

Apr 27 - Apr 28