Find Hotels by Benchmark in Upper Matecumbe Key from CA $341

"The perfect puppy friendly get away !! I still can’t believe I was able to relax under a huge shaded umbrella and take in the salty air with our dog by our side. This place was amazing. "

"This resort is a hidden GEM to the point that I almost don’t want to write about it because I don’t want everyone to know. We were freestyling it through the keys on our way to key west. After a light snack and cocktail at the Tiki Bar in Islamorada we decided we should find a place to spend the night. A quick search brought up many possibilities. We chose Lime Tree Bay because it looked quaint and quintessential Florida keys. We arrived to find an absolute gem. Clean, updated rooms with the most unbelievable views of the water set in a picture perfect backdrop of sand and water and a gorgeous new easy entry pool with palm trees swaying over the sand everywhere. The staff was incredibly nice and the other bloggers were fun and friendly. Parking is FREE!!!!! There’s a fantastic restaurant/bar right onsite. Shout out to Florida Boy Bar & Grille!!! Great food and drinks. I cannot wait to come back for a week!"

"Everything was perfect. Every detail has been thought of. The rooms were immaculate and so well decorated. The property is really well maintained. We loved all of the games around the resort as well. Highly recommend! "

"This was perfect for a Spring Break getaway to explore the entire length of the Florida Keys! We really enjoyed the pool, the breakfast and table service at breakfast, the glass bottom boat tour (discount for being hotel guests) and the lit up and covered pickleball court! Great stay!"

"Beautiful location, great amenities and comfortable rooms. Definitely coming back!!"

"Great place"

"Great stay, value, and area. "

"Excelent"

"The views were great, beds super comfy. People were slobs and left garbage around that was not picked up for quiet some time"