Find Hotels & Resorts for Couples in Shelter Island Heights, NY from CA $372

"Unable to rate beachfront, as our stay was off season , but, WHAT A VIEW!"

"I really enjoyed my two-night stay at Montauk Oceanside Suites. It's a very nice, quiet place to stay and also the beach is literally just across the street. Having never stayed there before, I was also very pleased with my room. Lots of nice touches (books, DVDs, chairs outside the room with a little table between them). My room was freshly painted with a comfortable bed and sofa. The dining table was by the window so you could look out at the view while you ate. I brought groceries to cook in the room, so the kitchenette was also a real bonus!"

"We loved the location of our room which opened right onto the sound. Stunning sunsets!!"

"excellent overall stay"

"Convenient, great value"

"All good "

"My fiancé and I had a lovely time. "

"Beautiful place. Wonderful staff"

"Everything was great from checking in to checking out. The rooms were very big and well maintained with a nice view to the waterfront. My only problem was that there was not enough parking at night. The parking area behind the hotel tends to get full, and most time it’s because people double park. It would be nice to have someone from the hotel guide people, or put some sort of markings, because that would allow for more room. Other than that, it was a great stay. "