Search Phelps Cottage Rentals

"This property was amazing! My husband and I spent our honeymoon here exploring the fingerlakes and this cottage was an amazing place to stay and relax between adventures! The views were spectacular!"

"This is our third year and have never been disappointed. Plan to return next year. Bob is very quick with answering questions and great host"

"Located at the end of a dirt road along the lake, this cozy home leaves little to be desired. It’s off the beaten path and provides seclusion as well close proximity to the wide variety of wineries and towns in the area. The host was wonderful; calling before our arrival to ensure there were no questions, and informing us of a temporary power outage the day we were to arrive. The home was well kept, fully stocked, and clean upon our arrival. The Finger Lakes is one of my favorite vacation...

"We had an amazing bachelorette weekend for a soon to be bride! The rental gave a perfect cottagey vibe with cute decorations and beautiful lakeside views. We enjoyed all sitting around the large dining room table and using the fire pit on the patio, as well as cooking on the grill for dinner! My only suggestion would be to include at least one full length mirror in the main house, and designated hampers for used towels. We had so much fun and really hope to visit again!!"

"2 couples, stayed there in mid November. House inside and out is practically brand new. Kitchen is well stocked, plenty of towels and linens. It was cold while we were there, but the outside deck is very large and spacious. Grill could use some help, and there are no TVs. Basement is a plus, but we didn't use it. Property manager lives right across the street and greeted us when we arrived to make sure everything was in order. When we come to the finger lakes, we will rent this house again."

"House was clean and convenient to all lakes and wineries. The house is not professionally constructed we had issues with the dishwasher. There was no storage is any of the bedrooms except the master. Overall it was fine but could use some improvement."

"The house was great with plenty of beds. We were there for the Ironman in Geneva. It was a quick ride to town. Surprisingly there were no TVs. Very comfortable and I recommend a stay here."

"Made reservation through 3rd party. Office had no record of it when I was checking in. I had to show that my account was debited for the rental. Area is very crowded with RVs. Was greeted by campers yelling at me to slow down, even though I was doing the tmph speed limit. Not a good environment if you don't have an RV."

"This was a terrific stay. Very clean and just as advertised. Very relaxing and would have no problem going back there again with the family."

"It was very relaxing. The place was very clean and accurate described. Ann Marie was very nice and very helpful. She willingly shared her knowledge and her grapes and plums as well. The only disappointment was not being able to catch a salmon. One day I will. The place itself is all I expected from a cabin on a lake. And for us the stair climb wasn’t that difficult. Loved the use of the rowboat and canoe.i definitely would stay again. We enjoyed."

"This wasnt the biggest property but it was the most perfect for a quick getaway for two. We will definitely go back-the location sitting right on the water is perfection. "

"The house was in a prime location - right on the lake! It was well equipped with all of the items we needed. We love to cook and did so every day. Everything was well thought out with the rental to make it as enjoyable as possible. The two story sunporch was amazing and when we were indoors that's where we were. Thanks, Janice for sharing your little puece of heaven with us."