Find Hotels by Independent in Islamorada from CA $232

"Beautiful property and very accommodating. "

"The property is older but very well maintained. HVAC system updated recently. Gounds are very nice for spending time outside. Beach area, boat docks, pool cabana, picnic tables, grills. Grills are cleaned by staff daily. They have kayaks and paddleboards for use. Service was great, all requests were taken care of."

"The resort was beautiful, clean, and well managed. We had a beautiful room with stylish furniture. Fun things to do at the resort (fish, swim, pitch and putt golf), within walking distance to other fun restaurants and stores. "

"My husband and I traveled to Amara Cay Resort for a 4 night stay and were very impressed with the whole experience. The room was very clean and comfortable. The food, drinks and service were excellent as well. We loved the reusable water bottles they gave us at check in, I have never been offered that before and thought it was a smart idea! They also had other great things they offered like a shuttle service and fishing. The beach and pool were beautiful even though it was too chilly for us to utilize the weekend we were here. If you’re traveling to Islamorada for business or vacation we definitely recommend staying at Amara Cay! "

"Great location, great beach, pools and staff. "

"It’s very relaxing with tropical feel. It feels like a private quiet island. Noel at the tiki bar was great. "

"The room was nice and clean with a shared balcony. Nice grounds and pool. Staff friendly. "

"Lovely quiet corner of Islamorada with superb water and sun access. "

"Nice staff, in the middle of everything in the keys, nice short walk or bike ride to Bayside Gourmet for lobster bisque and a great Cuban sandwich, and a short drive to Robbie's and a cruise with Sundance Water Sports on the "Blue", Excellent."