Top 10 Fire Island hotels and places to stay

Seasonal outdoor pool, open 10:00 AM to 8:00 PM, pool umbrellas

"Wonderful stay "

CA $230 total

includes taxes & fees

Mar 7 - Mar 8

"Great location, room layout was perfect, and easy check-in. "

CA $264 total

includes taxes & fees

Mar 7 - Mar 8

"Fully renovated property! Was blown away how nice it is, and rhe proximity to all the local hot spots!"

CA $263 total

includes taxes & fees

Mar 9 - Mar 10

"quiet convenient "

CA $240 total

includes taxes & fees

Apr 1 - Apr 2

"I'd like the quaintness about it I like the view. The location was fabulous"

"It’s ok. Not dirty, not spotless. It’s a nice little rural spot, perfect if spending days by some wineries "

CA $420 total

includes taxes & fees

Mar 10 - Mar 11

Deluxe Double Room, 1 King Bed, City View

"Small room but clean and just what we needed, had a great stay ! Convenient to shops, food and bars "

"Very quiet and clean! "

CA $385 total

includes taxes & fees

Mar 9 - Mar 10

"We stayed with Carole for two nights, and we absolutely loved her place! The location was perfect for us—central and convenient. From the moment we arrived, we felt right at home. She has created such a warm and cozy space, and her hospitality made all the difference. We truly appreciated her kindness and how welcoming she was. Without a doubt, we’ll be staying with her again the next time we visit Long Island!"

CA $246 total

includes taxes & fees

Apr 1 - Apr 2

"Felt like home"

CA $410 total

includes taxes & fees

Mar 7 - Mar 8

"Convenient. Clean. Value. "

CA $150 total

includes taxes & fees

Mar 9 - Mar 10

"The staff was very polite and friendly. The hotel was clean. Adorable picnic basket breakfast!!!! Winter igloo lounge was great!!! Definitely will be back!!!"

CA $343 total

includes taxes & fees

Mar 9 - Mar 10

CA $420 total

includes taxes & fees

Apr 6 - Apr 7

"The room itself was beautiful and clean. Front desk staff was wonderful, very polite and I was able to have early check in so we could get ready for my father n laws wake. Breakfast was great. Only issue was the pillows and bed, not comfortable at all. "

CA $177 total

includes taxes & fees

Mar 17 - Mar 18

"Great stay - very walkable to all! Staff was amazing. Breakfast was sparse but everything was clean and comfortable. Large room - would definitely recommend and stay again! "

CA $282 total

includes taxes & fees

Mar 20 - Mar 21